What defines a “good” salary at the start of one’s career? Is financial growth more important than job satisfaction and long-term stability? These are questions many young professionals grapple with, especially in a landscape where private sector pay scales and government benefits offer vastly different career experiences. One such case — a 22-year-old engineering graduate who recently chose a government research job over the private IT sector — has reignited this debate, particularly after friends told him that his Rs 18 lakh per annum offer was “too low.”
A Change in Path: From Coding to Research
The young man, a mechanical engineer from a Tier-3 college in Mumbai, began his professional journey in an IT firm with an annual salary of Rs 3.6 lakh. But he had long aspired to work in the research sector, which led him to prepare for competitive exams conducted by top central government research bodies. After clearing the selection process, he secured a position as a Scientific Officer in Mumbai.
His new role offers a compensation of Rs 18 lakh per annum along with multiple government perks — including health insurance for the entire family, a yearly domestic flight allowance, education support for children, and a guaranteed pension scheme reinstated from April. The job also comes with stability, non-transferability, and access to housing in premium Mumbai localities.
Unexpected Backlash from Friends
Despite the attractive package and benefits, the young scientist was taken aback when several of his peers expressed disappointment, claiming he was underselling himself. Many of these friends suggested that the IT sector would offer higher pay in the long term, although most of them were earning less than half of his current package.
Their comments left him confused, especially as some insisted that his salary growth would eventually fall behind theirs. Yet, data he shared indicated otherwise — a colleague with 14 years of experience in the same organisation currently earns around Rs 42 lakh, with upcoming pay commission revisions expected to increase this figure significantly.
Reddit Weighs In: Support for the Scientist
The post drew significant attention on Reddit, with many users rallying behind the scientist’s choice. One commenter pointed out that comparing his new salary to his previous Rs 3.6 lakh role should be the true benchmark, calling the jump “remarkable” at age 22.
Others stressed that many in the IT industry, even with 14–20 years of experience, face uncertainty due to rapid technological shifts and automation threats. The conversation noted that layoffs are becoming more frequent, and maintaining steady growth in IT often requires relentless upskilling. In contrast, a government research job offers predictability and peace of mind.
The Bigger Picture: Perks Beyond Pay
Several Reddit users highlighted that salary alone doesn’t reflect the complete value of a job. One person explained that the comprehensive benefits package — from healthcare and housing to pension and job security — makes the scientist’s position enviable. A few even mentioned how rare such perks are in the private sector, where long-term employment is no longer guaranteed.
Some users also suggested that the criticism he received from friends might stem from insecurity or jealousy. They cautioned him to reflect on the change in their behaviour, especially since the comments came from those earning significantly less.
In his own responses on the thread, the young scientist explained that he values meaningful work and a stable life over chasing higher numbers. He mentioned wanting enough income for occasional international travel with his parents, but not at the cost of work-life balance or job satisfaction.
He acknowledged that while his peers in IT might earn more in the short term, his current role aligns with his interests. He also expressed no desire to transition into tech fields like AI, citing his background and lack of motivation for further study.